autopediaReading progress, Istanbul Park
← All news

Electric · · 1 min read

Tesla Model Y finishes last of 109 models in Germany's TÜV report, with 18.5 percent failing

According to the 2027 TÜV Report, nearly one in five three-year-old Model Ys failed their first inspection because of major defects. It is the second year in a row the model has come bottom.

Tesla Model Y
Drawing: Autopedia. Tesla Model Y

The 2027 TÜV Report, which compiles Germany's mandatory roadworthiness tests, has been published. Based on 9.7 million inspections carried out between July 2025 and June 2026, it found major defects on 18.5 percent of Tesla Model Ys at their first inspection, at around three years old. A year earlier the figure was 17.3 percent. The Model Y came last of the 109 models in this age group for the second year running, at roughly three times the 6.4 percent average for cars of the same age.

The main problems were with the suspension and brakes. Worn suspension joints showed up on Model Ys 24 times as often as on comparable cars. Defective brake discs were found on 3.4 percent of cars, well above the 1 percent average, and there were more complaints than usual about the front lighting. Model Ys arrived for inspection with an average of 58,000 km, above the overall average of 47,000 km. The results cover cars built before the refreshed Model Y.

Electric cars sat at both ends of the report: they won three of the six classes but also filled the bottom three places overall. The Tesla Model 3 was third from bottom with a 12.5 percent failure rate. Second from bottom was the MG4 at 16 percent, with brake disc defects on 10.3 percent of cars, about ten times the average. At the other end of the table, the Mazda MX-30 was the best electric model at 3 percent and came third overall behind the Mazda CX-60 and Mercedes-Benz GLA.

This story was compiled in Turkish from the sources below and read and approved by a Autopedia editor before publishing.

More news